PDA

View Full Version : AUTOMATIC KAFKA #1 ADVANCE REVIEW


Anthony Zisa
Jun 18, 2002, 02:29 am
Reviewer: Anthony Zisa, PopinFrsh@aol.com
Quick Rating: Great!
Story Title: Metal Music Machine

Wildstorm's "Eye of the Storm" line of mature readers titles launches with sex, drugs, and synthetic life as Automatic Kafka takes a metaphoric and literal trip inside his own mind!

Written by: Joe Casey
Art by: Ashley Woods
Lettered by: Richard Starkings & Comicraft's Saida Temofonte
Assistant Editor: Kristy Quinn
Editor: Scott Dunbier

I hear the question already. "What is Automatic Kafka, and why should we care? This is an X-Men web site!" Well, Automatic Kafka is the latest project from one of the most controversial X-Men teams in recent history, Joe Casey and Ashley Wood. Their work on Uncanny X-Men #398 and the 2001 Annual was controversial, with a sharp divide of people who either loved the duo's work together or loathed it.

Automatic Kafka also marks the debut of the "Eye of the Storm" mature readers line of comics from Wildstorm, the DC imprint run by X-Men fan-favorite penciller Jim Lee. And if Automatic Kafka is any indication of the shape of things to come from "Eye of the Storm," the imprint will not be lacking for books that stand out in the glutted, homogeneous genre of superhero stories.

I'm an orphan of technology – Joe Casey's Kafka

The book derives its name from the protagonist, Kafka, an android superhero in the twilight of his relevancy, searching for self in nanotecheroin, a new breed of drugs designed for synthetic life. His chemical experimentation goes sour, however, and he finds himself on the wrong end of an overdose, saddled with a naked, female grim reaper with as sharp a tongue as scythe. Death brings Kafka on a journey inside his own mind, forcing him to face his inner demons, his past, and his present – all while blurring the lines between the three.

And, at the outset, Kafka has many demons to face. A former member of a team of superheroes known as The $trangers, put together and bankrolled by a wealthy industrialist, Kafka had a good life – seven years ago. Righteous, heroic, and a ladies' man, Kafka was ironic envied by the very same humans he would give anything to become. At some point, however, the good life evaporated, leaving Kafka where he is when the reader meets him – searching for self, for that elusive trace of humanity his synthetic life denies him. In interviews, Casey has stated that Automatic Kafka comes from a very personal, very dark place in himself, and that shines through in the writing. It is pure Casey, with sharp dialogue and plenty of dark themes and ideas permeating the story.

Okay, enough existentialism... a little mayhem, anyone...? – Death

Delightfully mad concepts masquerade as mundane in Kafka's world, with off-the-wall segues such as tiny devils shilling nanotecheroin on television, and Death critiquing Kafka's mid-nineties fashion sense. There are tantalizing glimpses of Kafka's world, which Casey intelligently keeps brief – a mere whetting of the palette, intended to intrigue, rather than explicate. They are a small sense of the world, while focusing on the inception of Kafka's mission.

Once again, Casey smartly ties the mission into Kafka's identity. A lot of information about Kafka is delivered in this issue, but at the same time, the method of delivery never jars the reader. Kafka's quest inside his own head sets tone of the book – a weird, wholly unique journey to discover what lies beneath our self-perceived past.

Adding to the uniqueness of Automatic Kafka is artist Ashley Wood, channeling Bill Sienkewicz and Dave McKean, while at the same time creating his own dark visual style. His visuals are oftentimes brilliant, and always perfectly suited to the ideas Casey sets forth. On the third page, Wood brings a television advertisement for nanotecheroin to life, creating the punch line through his artwork. Similarly, on page five, he creates a gorgeous representation of Kafka's mind, with plenty of hints at future revelations. For each mad idea, or stark mental picture, Casey set forth, Wood matched with equally intense artwork. From Kafka's journey over his own prone body to the techno graveyard to a wonderfully Animal Man-esque insertion of artist into art, Wood ups the ante of Casey's story, daring the audience to ignore the energy of Automatic Kafka.

Yet, it is in his character design, however, that some of Wood's most brilliant work shines through. The characters, as realized by Casey and Wood, find their own voices and personalities immediately. Particularly Death, whose razor wit and flippant demeanor shines through in both Casey's dialogue and Wood's artwork. She is dangerous, sexy, and unpredictable, the full embodiment of all that scary about the end of life – a living embodiment of the human Death Wish. Kafka, too, becomes well realized. He is deeply conflicted, and apparently deeply jaded to the world. For all his fame and fortune garnered during his time as a professional superhero, he is still unhappy, seeking something more... and afraid of his place in "the techno graveyard, home of the obsolete."

Yet, for all the good, Automatic Kafka #1 is not perfect. Disguised as it is by the visuals and trippy, dreamlike story, there is a lot of exposition. It is a difference of opinions about aesthetics, to be sure, but still a minor problem. However, in consideration that this is an introductory issue, this quibble is easily overlooked, as future issues are sure to be less exposition heavy and more action oriented.

Finally, be forewarned – this title is a mature readers title for a reason. Casey, controlled by the limitations of mainstream work in the past, fully cuts loose, touching on everything that makes watchdog groups smell blood. Nudity, numerous drug references, and sexual themes are the norm throughout the book. Fair warning has been given.

In this intense first issue, as the lines between reality and fiction, life and death, the past and present all begin to blur, Kafka is reborn with a new mission – to find himself. And by the time that rebirth occurs, the reader is all too eager to join him on his odd quest of self-discovery.

Automatic Kafka #1 ships July 17th. Check it out for some guaranteed weirdness.

ART:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

STORY:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

OVERALL:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

Buy this issue online now from X-World Comics (http://www.x-worldcomics.com/x/bstore/newbooksmain.html) and save!

Benjamin Ong
Jun 18, 2002, 02:40 am
Great review, AZ. Can't wait!

spinarakboi
Jun 18, 2002, 03:28 am
Never even heard of this... hmm.

Benjamin Ong
Jun 18, 2002, 03:53 am
Originally posted by spinarakboi
Never even heard of this... hmm.

Too much X-Men perhaps? :D Seriously, there're other good books out there too ;)

strangerx
Jun 18, 2002, 04:41 am
I have been looking forward to this (as well as Casey's Hip Flask) for some time, and I'm glad to hear it get a good review. I think that Casey and Wood were great together in the annual and I can't wait to get this book.

Casey is such a great writer and Wood an excelent artist that I would be a fool to miss out on this.

spinarakboi
Jun 18, 2002, 04:49 am
Originally posted by xpawn


Too much X-Men perhaps? :D Seriously, there're other good books out there too ;)

Exactly, I collect and give titles a chance as long as it has an X in it's name. I mean I dont read Deadpool and never really wanted to but I'm excited about Agent X... Ah well. I'm sure there is a lot of good comics out there I'm missing and if anyone wants to pm with good titles feel free ^_^

Stochastic Fats
Jun 18, 2002, 09:40 am
Originally posted by spinarakboi


Exactly, I collect and give titles a chance as long as it has an X in it's name. I mean I dont read Deadpool and never really wanted to but I'm excited about Agent X...

My god, I thought this was just a tired industry joke, but I guessing you're serious. Ever heard of New Mutants?

AK has long been pre-ordered from Previews.
Sounds wild.

Anthony Zisa
Jun 18, 2002, 11:49 am
The kind words about Automatic Kafka are well deserved. Between this book, Micah Wright's Stormwatch book, and Wildcats 3.0, the mature readers line is in good hands.

Then, you have Global Frequency coming from the regular imprint, so Wildstorm is going to have some serious buzz swirling around it in the next few months, with all these high profile, high quality launches.

Looks like I'm going to be culling the dead weight in Marvel and X-Men books from my pull list to make some room...

--acz

Bamfette
Jun 18, 2002, 05:07 pm
I've been waiting for this one, as i was one of the ones who LOVED the annual. sounds great! will definately be picking it up ;)

Benjamin Ong
Jun 19, 2002, 01:41 am
Looks like I'm going to be culling the dead weight in Marvel and X-Men books from my pull list to make some room...

--acz


What took you so long? ;) I've been culling titles in favour of better ones for some time...

ultimateweaponx
Jun 19, 2002, 02:19 am
Comics written while on Acid - a must read!

Anthony Zisa
Jun 19, 2002, 03:24 am
Originally posted by ultimateweaponx
Comics written while on Acid - a must read!

Heh, I can't speak for Joe, obviously, but as far as I know, the comic wasn't written on acid. However, it would read quite well were you to accidentally ingest a tablet and break out the book.

--acz

Ryan Scott
Jun 19, 2002, 03:40 am
Beautiful review, Ant! I must say, I've been on the fence on this series. Not because of the creators involved (I LOVED the annual, for instance), but because of monetary situation. After reading this review, I'm STILL in that position, but it's REALLY hard not to be :) If ever released in trades, I'm SO there. I hope I'm financially stable enough to get the single issues when it finally ships, though. We'll see :-\

Benjamin Ong
Jun 19, 2002, 08:33 am
Oh I'm sure it'll be collected in a trade, and I think it'll be cheaper than all the issues involved combined.

Anthony Zisa
Jun 19, 2002, 04:23 pm
Originally posted by xpawn
Oh I'm sure it'll be collected in a trade, and I think it'll be cheaper than all the issues involved combined.

A mindset that's seen many a book go bye-bye.

Buy the singles, or there won't be a trade, AND the book will get cancelled. If you're interested, part with the money now, get it off to a running start, and then when it gets traded, sell off the singles and pick up the trade. The reason series fail (SWAMP THING, OUTLAW NATION, etc) that would sell well in trade format is because there's not enough sales due to the "wait for the trade" mentality.

Once a trade is available, start picking it up in trade. But if no one supports it in single format, there won't be a trade to pick up.

--acz

stormwatch
Jun 19, 2002, 08:20 pm
Good review, as another who loved the annual, I have been awaiting this eagerly.

And I've been cutting down on my marvel and X-Titles to do it.

Benjamin Ong
Jun 20, 2002, 12:26 am
Originally posted by Anthony Zisa


Buy the singles, or there won't be a trade, AND the book will get cancelled. If you're interested, part with the money now, get it off to a running start, and then when it gets traded, sell off the singles and pick up the trade.

--acz

Easy for you to say, but if you're in this part of the world... :( There's this Japanese book store here that sell really, really cheap trades and their business is really good. Trades are selling much better than the single issues that they're cutting down orders for singles.

I know that the act of waiting for trades would spell doom for the singles but it's all about costs here, as comics these days aren't cheap.

And most of the time, only the first couple of arcs or so are good, before the publishers decide to change the creative teams. Besides, comics readers these days follow creators, anyway. If the creators themselves are not committed to the books long term, you surely don't expect readers to do the same, right?

King Edward III
Jun 20, 2002, 01:20 am
Originally posted by Anthony Zisa


A mindset that's seen many a book go bye-bye.

Buy the singles, or there won't be a trade, AND the book will get cancelled. If you're interested, part with the money now, get it off to a running start, and then when it gets traded, sell off the singles and pick up the trade. The reason series fail (SWAMP THING, OUTLAW NATION, etc) that would sell well in trade format is because there's not enough sales due to the "wait for the trade" mentality.

Unfortunately, this is true.

The Monarchy issue sales decreased as the series went on, dropping to bottom bar numbers, but the trade sales were among the best. Sadly, it didn't matter, because the series had been cancelled before the trade's release.

The idea sounds interesting, and if it was anyone other than Casey/Wood I might be genuinely intrigued, but as it is I don't plan to pick this up.

Anthony Zisa
Jun 20, 2002, 01:30 am
Originally posted by xpawn
Besides, comics readers these days follow creators, anyway. If the creators themselves are not committed to the books long term, you surely don't expect readers to do the same, right?

Automatic Kafka is creator owned (or participation) work. Joe and Ashley are committed to this as long as they have planned (if it's a closed ended series), or as long as they'll be allowed to print (ie: so long as the singles are selling, or trades are moving enough to allow the singles to be loss leaders on the trades).

--acz

King Edward III
Jun 20, 2002, 01:58 am
Automatic Kafka is creator owned? Are you sure of this?

Anthony Zisa
Jun 20, 2002, 02:19 am
Originally posted by King Edward III
Automatic Kafka is creator owned? Are you sure of this?

At the very least, it's participation, like Planetary. It's got the "Created by Joe Casey and Ashley Wood" credit on the title page, which usually denotes, in the Wildstorm business structure, participation/ownership.

--acz

King Edward III
Jun 20, 2002, 02:53 am
A "created by" tag doesn't equate a creator owned series.

I can respect Casey's intentions here, it does look like he's trying to do something different, but from what I've read of his in the past he doesn't deliver on what he promises, and that lack of execution leaves me with a general distaste for whatever I see him on even before reading it. I'd like to say I'm a fair and unbiased reader, but I'm not, I can't be, and it's hard to muster genuine interest in something when you instinctively dismiss the notion of it being a quality product from the author's name.

King Edward III
Jul 5, 2002, 03:09 am
Automatic Kafka's numbers are in, it debuted at number 125 on the chart's this week.

Anthony Zisa
Jul 5, 2002, 05:19 am
Originally posted by King Edward III
Automatic Kafka's numbers are in, it debuted at number 125 on the chart's this week.

Are you saying this is a bad thing, or a good thing? It's a mature readers Wildstorm non-continuity title. Of course it's going to be low, even with creators of the caliber of Joe and Ashley at the helm. Sadly, people fear the new, and people in comics tend to fear the non-spandex and weird.

The question will be, will the debut sell out, will reorders be necessary, and will the readers level out quickly. After all, initial orders mean precisely dick in comics, as comics can sit on the shelves unsold for months before being relegated to the quarter bin.

I can still buy X-Men #1 for less than a buck, new condition. And that had the largest ordered debut ever.

--acz

King Edward III
Jul 5, 2002, 09:54 pm
I think it's pretty obvious that 125 is not a good thing, and is not what Casey and Wildstorm were hoping for.

Stormwatch: Team Achilles debuted at 68, which isn't great, but it's considerably better, and it bears the mature label too(and a familiar name).

Benjamin Ong
Jul 5, 2002, 11:58 pm
Guys, remember, The Authority did do well in pre-order numbers until months later...

Anthony Zisa
Jul 8, 2002, 04:52 pm
Originally posted by King Edward III
I think it's pretty obvious that 125 is not a good thing, and is not what Casey and Wildstorm were hoping for.

Stormwatch: Team Achilles debuted at 68, which isn't great, but it's considerably better, and it bears the mature label too(and a familiar name).

It's a weird, non-established book. As you said, Stormwatch has the Stormwatch name and connection to the Authority behind it, whereas Automatic Kafka has nothing behind it, save the creative team, which is still not a huge seller in the comics marketplace.

The book's good. If the quality remains on par with what I saw, word of mouth will build, people will check it out, a trade will come out, and the book's life will be solidified until the final issue (well, obviously, but I meant the final issue Joe and Ashley plan, as part of what seems to be a closed ended book).

It'll never blaze up sales charts, because it is weird, but it'll find a happy medium. Debuting low, when you're a weird, Wildstorm book featuring no familiar characters with nothing but the hook of promised weirdness is not a bad thing. However, crying its death knell prior to the book even being released IS a bad thing for the book.

--acz

King Edward III
Jul 8, 2002, 08:36 pm
If I cry it's death(which I don't), it's only because I don't care for it or the creator.

Considering the amount of press Wildstorm's relaunch is getting, I find it hard to buy the "it's a weird book and thus isn't recognizable" theory. I belive there is something readers recognize, and that's the name "Casey" on the cover. Casey isn't too popular with Wildstorm fans, perhaps comic fans in general, and barring a radical change I can't see him authoring a popular, well selling book(which of course doesn't equate quality) outside the X-Men/Superman franchise, where everything sells.

If I'm wrong, great, comics need good books right now, and while I don't consider him a talented writer, I certainly wouldn't deny that he's attempting to do something different within the medium.

strangerx
Jul 9, 2002, 06:02 am
To me, I don't really care that the book debuted low, that was almost expected as others have said, its an outthere book with only it's creaters names to back it up.

All that I really care about is that my comic book store gets in at least one copy so that I can pick this up. I think Joes a great writer and that Ashley Wood compliments him nicely.

This is one book that I am really looking forward to.

enzymeXIV
Jul 11, 2002, 02:13 am
After months of deliberation, I've decided to pass on AK.

I love Ashley Wood; but, as another poster mentioned earlier, Joe Casey usually leaves much to be desired. The sense that I've gotten when I've read his stuff in the past has been that he desperately wants to give off the veneer of "cool", but can't seem to provide the goods to back it up, y'know?

I'll keep getting my precious Ashley Wood fix from Popbot, thank you very much, and pass on yet another DC comic. (They still haven't proven to me that they're at all interested in taking my cash anymore.)

King Edward III
Jul 11, 2002, 02:52 am
It's the Hyde to Zisa's Jeykl.

Anthony Zisa
Jul 17, 2002, 11:04 am
AUTOMATIC KAFKA #1 is out today! Don't forget to buy it! And if you dig it, tell your retailer to pre-order you a copy! Help support this weird little book by two A-list creators!

--acz

Benjamin Ong
Jul 17, 2002, 11:28 am
I'm sure gonna be checking this out on Sat...!

strangerx
Jul 18, 2002, 06:44 am
I was able to pick this book up, and it was fantastic. It's weird and off beat, but incredible at the same time. Joe Casey has written a powerful and intriging story, which Ashley Woods art compliments perfectly. It really sets the tone for the book and gives it a real unique feel.

I can't wait for the next issue.

Benjamin Ong
Jul 23, 2002, 07:26 am
Check out what Joe Casey himself has to say by clicking here (http://dcboards.warnerbros.com/files/Forum37/HTML/002686.html)