PDA

View Full Version : ANGEL 5 x 16 ‘SHELLS’ REVIEW


Steven Paul
Mar 30, 2004, 03:00 pm
Reviewer: Steven Paul Watson vipereyes_2000@yahoo.com
Quick Rating: Great!
Story Title: ‘Shells’

An old one returns to a new world.

Writer/Director: Steven S. DeKnight
Cast: David Boreanaz, Alexis Denisof, J. August Richards, Amy Acker, James Marsters, and Andy Hallett.

Warning: Some Spoilers Ahead!

With the recent news of Angel’s cancellation at the end of its current fifth season it makes it somewhat depressing to watch the remaining episodes, especially when those episodes are like the extremely funny ‘Smile Time’, the very exciting and dramatic ‘You're Welcome’, the thrilling ‘Damage’, and the powerful (and some would say one of the best episodes of Angel ever) ‘A Hole in the World.’ In fact a lot of this season of Angel has been exceptional and makes one ask “why won’t there be a sixth season?”

We can only hope that the remainder of this season continues to be as good as the past few episodes. It is easy to see why fans of the show (like myself) get so attached to these characters and their stories. Angel at it’s worst is still a great escape from reality for an hour a week.

An excellent example of Angel’s typical offering to its fans is the episode, ‘Shells’ and it does not disappoint. It begins where the last episode ends with Wes now facing what is his greatest fear. Like the last episode was about Fred and how her ‘illness’ affected everyone around them. It affected no one as much as it did Wes; Fred after all was the love of his life. And Wes is the first who must face the ‘Old One’ who now inhabits Fred’s body.

From there, Angel and Spike return and the group try to figure out how to stop Illyria and who all was involved in bringing her to Wolfram & Hart. Two ill-fated confrontations with her and a visit to her temple before the end of this action packed episode and you know Angel Inc is out of luck.

This episode is a turning point in Spike and Angel’s relationship: they don’t get along but they know they must work together and get past their own personal feelings. It’s what Fred would have wanted.

Probably one of the less talked about points of this episode is Gunn’s role in bringing Illyria to Wolfram & Hart. In wanting to be something that he is not, to be more than the muscle of the group, he is the cause for everything that is happening. If not for him Illyria would have never ended up at Wolfram & Hart or infected Fred. When Wes finds out he is initially shocked in explaining his feelings to Gunn, but he understood why he did it. But the one thing Wes could not forgive is Gunn not coming forward and telling the others when he learned about his role in tragic events.

Illyria is an interesting character, sort of a pinch of Jasmine and Glory in one. The world is not what she expected it to be on her return to the living. After all she says it herself she thought the human race would have died out long ago and by the end she is set up to be completely different from the other two God like entities that have had a presence in the Buffyverse (not saying Illyria is a god though, just a demon before the time of man, an ‘Old one’ as they are called).

The conclusion of the episode brings the real questions, what next? And Spike says it best when he talking to Angel “Lot bigger than Illyria” he says about a battle is coming and he may be right. And just where does Illyria fit into the coming battle? And just how will losing Fred affect them in the long run? All of these questions are sure to be answered once new episodes begin to air, but now we can only wait and see.

The direction of the episode continues the same theme that began pretty much since the first scenes of this season. Angel Inc is out of place at Wolfram & Hart, they are the good guys and Wolfram & Hart are the bad guys. And they keep getting the constant reminders that going there could be the worst mistakes of their lives. And the first real causality is Fred. Sure not to be the last. It only adds to the disappointment that this looks like it will be Angel’s last season as the episodes finally come together to make it one of its better seasons. Plus with its premature ending, there are a lot of plots and stories yet to be told or explained that don’t look like they will ever see the small screen.

Like Amy Acker’s acting in ‘A Hole in the World’, this episode was a stand out for a lot of the cast, especially for Alexis Denisof who plays the some times geek, sometimes complete bad ass ex-Watcher Wesley. He is especially powerful in the scenes where he talks about being with Fred when Illyria awakens.

I can’t give an honest review of the episode if I don’t at least mention the song “A Place Called Home” by Kim Richey and it is the song that is played at the end of ‘Shells.’ So often it is hard to pick the perfect song to bring the audience into the episode and give off the emotion of what is going on. I thought this was the perfect song for the end of ‘Shells’ as we get to see what all of the characters are doing, their frame of mind, and a flashback. The perfect song goes a long way.

OVERALL:
http://www.comixfan.com/xfan/images/reviews/mfull.jpg http://www.comixfan.com/xfan/images/reviews/mfull.jpg http://www.comixfan.com/xfan/images/reviews/mfull.jpg http://www.comixfan.com/xfan/images/reviews/mfull.jpg http://www.comixfan.com/xfan/images/reviews/mnone.jpg

Colonel Cortez
Mar 30, 2004, 03:24 pm
Im still not sure wheter I like Illyria or not, hopefully she'll be better than Fred anyway.

When is the next ep, if it's next week I'll be in the States for it?

Good review Steve:)

bugalugs1
Mar 30, 2004, 03:30 pm
Loving this season, certainly not seen some of the character arcs that have happened since the start of it, especially in "You're Welcome" <huge sobs!> and "A hole In The World" <more sobs!>

Certainly there's not fairness that the show should be goping when they are pulling out all the stops like this.

And even more interested to see how the end of the season is going to pan out with only, what 9 episodes left to start tying everything together.

Does anyone else want the final scenes of the show to be Angel going back to his "roots" and re-opening the old Detective Agency (even better if it was the old building from S1!) and the final shot to be either Angel strutting down the alleyway, or him in his chair in the office (possibly with Wesley?) to have a call come in and Cordelia's voice on the answering machine "Angel Investigations....we help the helpless..." cut to Angel smiling...<fade to black>
I really don't want him to Sanshu to be honest!

And massive YAY for starting to do some more "genre" reviews than just comics, might have to start thinking about asking to do Alias or Smallville ones (can't see West Wing, Shield or 24 fitting in the overall theme!)

Killah
Mar 30, 2004, 04:20 pm
Well, this is just fine and dandy, peachy-keen.

BUT this is also getting a little bit ridicioulous. I mean, ain't this supposed to be a comic book site? Then why the heck post movie and tv-series' reviews ?! What's the point?

I bet that next time I come to this site, there are gonna be some porn mags' reviews! :eek:

Otherwise, nice review. No offence to the author for the comment above.

bugalugs1
Mar 30, 2004, 04:33 pm
Nobody asks you to click on the link..
Not interested? Don't clcik. It's as simple as that.
I'm not a great Indy comics fan, doesn't mean I should go around saying they shouldn't be reviewing them. I just don't read them!

Now, back to the show at hand...I'm not convinced about Illyria (why do I wnat to write Illyana every time!) in the last few episodes I'd really feel Fred was becoming more rounded as a character.
Sure she didn't add the sizzle factor that Cordy did or Lilah could have done, but I *liked* her...
I'm very interested to see how Illy's arc will be contracted to accomodate the lack of a following season though...

Sage4ever
Mar 30, 2004, 04:52 pm
I absolutely loved this episode! I'm loving this season, and it seems like this show is going from strength to strength... can someone remind me again why they are cancelling it?

I don't think the magnitude of what happened to Fred really hit me until the final montage! I have to admit that I'm a sucker for montages but this one was so simple and about Fred and had moving music that I actually shed an actual tear! That never happens! But anyway.... completely loved this episode.

bugalugs1
Mar 30, 2004, 04:56 pm
Originally posted by Sage4ever
I absolutely loved this episode! I'm loving this season, and it seems like this show is going from strength to strength... can someone remind me again why they are cancelling it?


Cos they're idiots as Cordy would say..


I don't think the magnitude of what happened to Fred really hit me until the final montage! I have to admit that I'm a sucker for montages but this one was so simple and about Fred and had moving music that I actually shed an actual tear! That never happens! But anyway.... completely loved this episode.

You mean you didn't sob like a little girl at the end of "You're Welcome"?? Man, you're a stronger person than I was!
What made that one worse was that I'd completely missed any spoilers on the real end of the episode, so when the phonecall happened I was taken totally by surprise.
Fred's turn however I'd heard about, but it still made me weep, sounds like at exactly the same moment you did too!!

Douglas Cuckler
Mar 30, 2004, 05:32 pm
Great review Steve. I wish I could have seen it :( .

citizenx
Mar 30, 2004, 05:41 pm
Originally posted by Killah
Well, this is just fine and dandy, peachy-keen.

BUT this is also getting a little bit ridicioulous. I mean, ain't this supposed to be a comic book site? Then why the heck post movie and tv-series' reviews ?! What's the point?



No offense, but Hellboy is a movie based off a comic (which you probably knew) and as far as I'm concerned, Angel is pretty much a live action comic book and couple that with the fact that series creator Joss Whedon will be writing X-Men, it makes sense to have such reviews. Plus, while comics may be the main focus of the site, it's not the only thing here.

Good review by the way. It was a great episode and it's a shame there's only 6 episodes left of the series.......

GuyX
Mar 30, 2004, 06:37 pm
This 5th season awesome...sadly it is the first i've ever watched. I'm doing a lot of catch up work with dvd's now, but I've loved the last 7 episodes this season.

A big loss to television when this thing goes off. Here's a cheers to the last 6 episodes :cheers:

Sage4ever
Mar 30, 2004, 07:18 pm
Originally posted by bugalugs1


You mean you didn't sob like a little girl at the end of &quot;You're Welcome&quot;?? Man, you're a stronger person than I was!
What made that one worse was that I'd completely missed any spoilers on the real end of the episode, so when the phonecall happened I was taken totally by surprise.
Fred's turn however I'd heard about, but it still made me weep, sounds like at exactly the same moment you did too!!

Oops, I forgot about that time. It still hurts. I was feeling so emotionally spent after that episode that I just moped around the following day until one of my flatmates plucked up the courage to tell me "it's only a show". As if! The telephone call at the end of that episode was gut-wrenching, especially after Cordelia has been on form that whole episode! That was the Cordelia we needed in Season 4, which also happened to be the Cordelia that would have gone down a storm in Season 5 too!

Radiate
Mar 31, 2004, 12:46 pm
What got me about Cordy was the fact that we only saw the REAL Cordy for 3 seasons since she wasn't the real one in 4...I felt robbed:(

BUt great review.Nice to know that Angel is being acknowledged on ComiX-Fan hope to see some more:yes:

RADIATE!

Sage4ever
Mar 31, 2004, 03:44 pm
Originally posted by Radiate

But great review. Nice to know that Angel is being acknowledged on ComiX-Fan hope to see some more:yes:

RADIATE!

Ditto... even though there's a bit of a wait for the next episode!

Jordan T. Maxwell
Mar 31, 2004, 05:08 pm
hmm...not exactly "current events" here, but a nice review all the same. so close to new episodes, though, i had to stop for a second and figure out if this was a review of the last new episode or if Steven had managed to get his hands on an advance copy of the upcoming episode (only two weeks now).

oh yeah, and anyone who's got a problem with Fred must answer to me. She's the best thing ever to happen for this show...and that's saying a LOT since i've thought "Angel" has been consistently one of the better shows on television. What can i say? I love me some Fred...sniff...or...sniff...loved me some Fred...

damn that Joss Whedon...first Tara, now Fred...what, Joss, you have to kill off EVERY fictional character i get a crush on? christ, you even had Kaylee take that shot in the gut in the Firefly pilot. i mean, she pulled through, but still...

oh no...he's writing Kitty next!

:hrm:

David Santee
Apr 1, 2004, 12:25 am
Originally posted by Killah
Well, this is just fine and dandy, peachy-keen.

BUT this is also getting a little bit ridicioulous. I mean, ain't this supposed to be a comic book site? Then why the heck post movie and tv-series' reviews ?! What's the point?

Well, why not have a review of Angel. It's one of the more active threads here at ComiX-Fan, so there is interest. If it brings some attention to the site, I'm all for it.

All the reviewers here at Comix-Fan are volunteers, giving thier time to help produce content for ya'all to read. Steve showed an interest in reviewing Angel, and I give him my full support.


The point is that many people who post here are interested in this show. It may also gather interest from people who didn't know about the site, thus introducing them to the comic world.. It's all good to me.

I bet that next time I come to this site, there are gonna be some porn mags' reviews! :eek:

Being an all-ages forum, I doubt any porn would get reviewed, but if an interested party made a good review, why not?

Otherwise, nice review. No offence to the author for the comment above.

Thats cool, I'm glad you shared your opinion. I just think there is no harm in spreading out from just comic books, as long as it dosn't take away from coverage of comic books, which it dosn't.

Looking foward to your next review, Steve. Great start.


Jordan, please don't make me worry about Kitty...but darn it, you have a point. That gave me an idea, though.....Firefly the comic book! MORE KAYLEE!

Steven Paul
Apr 2, 2004, 11:19 am
Thanks everyone!

I don't think the review would have been half as good with out Brian's help.